A Test Scenario, a Bug Report Deferred As-Designed: 437,000 Toyota Priuses Recalled

According to Associate Press (February 9, 2010, Yuri Kageyama, AP Business Writer), “Toyota is recalling 437,000 Prius and other hybrid vehicles worldwide to fix brake problem.” Toyota is the world’s largest automaker with impeccable quality reputation up to now.

As it turns out, the cause of the problem is a bug in the software that controls the brake system. “There have been about 200 complaints in Japan and the U.S. about a delay when the brakes in the Prius were pressed in cold conditions and on some bumpy roads. The delay doesn’t indicate a brake failure. The company says the problem can be fixed in 40 minutes with new software that oversees the controls of the antilock brakes.”

I don’t mean to wage in on Toyota disastrous situation. I just think that this is an essential software testing lesson and it illustrates some key issues that testers like us have experienced over the years. “After receiving a similar report from the U.S. in October, Toyota’s tests concluded that a glitch in the Prius antilock brake system software could reduce braking force when drivers traveled across bumpy surfaces. The company wrote that “although this system was operating as intended,” it decided to make a change to its production line in January to address the problem,” Kareyama reported. If I wrote a bug report, it would look like this:

  • Bug Report Summary: Braking force is reduced (the problem) when driving across bumpy surface (the scenario).
  • Reproducibility: Intermittent

It seems that the Resolution can be treated as “As-designed” (although it does not work in certain scenarios, that was how Toyota designed it), or “Deferred” (the problem is acknowledged and will be fixed later), or “To-be-fixed” (but in the next release). We already know the outcome. So, what do we learn?

  • Scenario-based and exploratory testing during system-test is essential—this requires skill and creativity in test design, not test-driven development (which is all good and an essential element to software development) or process-driven testing such as CMMi or ISO-9000 (which is good for quality control).
  • Software testing is not quality assurance—testers can report bugs, but a decision for corrective action lies somewhere else. There is nothing wrong with that. Testing is an important information service provider. We find and report problems.
  • Software is everywhere; and software is buggy—our job as testers is to find bug by breaking software in every possible way we can!

Last but not least, we, testers don’t create software or product; we help improve software reliability through our bug finding skills. Buy breaking software, we are saving consumer and our company time and money (even contributing to public safety in this case). So, keep breaking software tester…Your job is much appreciated!

LogiGear Corporation
LogiGear Corporation provides global solutions for software testing, and offers public and corporate software testing training programs worldwide through LogiGear University. LogiGear is a leader in the integration of test automation, offshore resources and US project management for fast, cost-effective results. Since 1994, LogiGear has worked with Fortune 500 companies to early-stage start-ups in, creating unique solutions to meet their clients’ needs. With facilities in the US and Viet Nam, LogiGear helps companies double their test coverage and improve software quality while reducing testing time and cutting costs.

The Related Post

Exploring key competences that endow a good games tester In this article, I will explore what I feel are the most important skills and attributes of a good game tester, and what type of mindset is needed for games testing.  I believe a good game tester should have. This is based on my experience and ...
Gondola by TestArchitect is a low-code Test Automation solution for End-to-End Testing across Web, API, and Mobile Applications. Gondola builds upon the TestArchitect family’s already-powerful testing capabilities in many ways, including faster mobile and web testing as well as heightened support for mobile application testing. LogiGear Product Manager Thuc Nguyen delves into why LogiGear created ...
Most software engineers intuitively perform BVA to some degree. By applying these guidelines, boundary testing will be more complete, thereby having a higher likelihood for error detection. Software is tested from two different perspectives: 1. Internal program logic is exercised using “white box” test case design techniques. 2. Software requirements are exercised using “black box” test case ...
Lab team brainstorming session Whether you work in engineering/product, operations, or even marketing, keeping your team trained and engaged with their work is a challenge that is universal for all managers. This is hard enough when your team is in-house, but what are you to do, when you have multiple teams to manage across different ...
A few months ago, Dr. Rebecca Fiedler and I published BBST—Test Design. This third course completes the Black Box Software Testing (BBST) set. The other two courses are BB ST Foundations and BBST Bug Advocacy. This article offers some information about the series, the design of the series (and the underlying instructional theory) and why you might be ...
LogiGear Magazine September 2012 – Integrated Test Platforms
BrianBrian is a delivery-focused manager with a wealth of multi-disciplinary IT experience, the last fifteen years of which have been mainly in quality assurance and testing. He has been fortunate enough to work for some of the world’s largest companies using some of the latest technologies and tools.As well as being responsible for the day-to-day ...
LogiGear Magazine – February 2011 – The Exploratory Testing Issue
If you want to enjoy your job and not worry about lack of resources, or have old, outdated strategies, with failing or meaningless test automation – get help!   We all know about globalization. Markets are global, products are global, mobile is global and software development is a global. As a result, the workforce is ...
Incorporate Exploratory Testing into your Test Strategy and find better bugs faster! Description: This two-day course is designed to give test engineers a global understanding of exploratory testing. From why we do it and its uses to how we do it and the value of measurement, Exploratory Testing will be examined and practiced to empower ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Stay in the loop with the lastest
software testing news