Centralize? Decentralize? Concentralize!

As I wrote in various articles, organization is one of the 3 key requisites for successful automated testing, the other two being test design and automation architecture.

A question coming up quite commonly in larger corporations and organizations is whether to centralize the test automation, either at division or corporate level, or whether to decentralize: distribute over the various groups and projects.

The question centralize/decentralize is probably one of the most common in organizational science, and numerous publications can be found on the topic. In my own experience as management I found that there is not one “good” solution. Both centralizing and decentralizing have advantages and disadvantages. The arguments for centralization are leveraging of knowledge, tools and environments. A strong central group can acquire the tools and equipment, and allocate them efficiently to various projects. They can also specialize in the various technical and non-technical aspect of testing and test automation, building knowledge, like testing and automation techniques, and create common libraries and in-house tools for various needs.

A decentralized organization of testing brings it closer to the project and the subject matter. The project manager will generally have a better grip on the activities, quality, timelines and costs involved. And it will generally be easier to leverage subject matter expertise when the testing are organized locally, even in some cases have the subject matter experts involved in test creation. However, it is more challenging to reach the same professional level, in particular for the automation part, and automation efforts can go lost after a project has finished, either by ineffective automation strategies, or simply because nobody is left to take care of the developed test-ware.

For automated testing however, I feel there is a good hybrid solution, which I like to nick-name “concentralize”. It would typically look something like this:

In this solution a core group concerns with activities like:

  • know how, methods and techniques
  • technology, tools (both acquired and in-house)
  • common libraries, actions and interface definitions
  • environments, like server racks, virtual machines, etc
  • retaining and preserving developed testware

The core group supports testing teams that are local, meaning inside or close to projects and departments. Within the test teams there is distinct:

  • test development, that includes:
    • high level test design, and test development planning
    • design development of test modules
  • project level automation, as much as possible distinct from the test development. It will typically entail activities like project level actions, interface handling, and scripting (see the Action Based Testing method for more details how this can work)

The testing teams in turn work with, and answer to, the various stakeholders, for input and assessment of developed test modules and their execution results.

In addition to the formal organization I recommend to have at least some form of informal “networking”. This could take the form of “special interest groups” for fields like test design and automation techniques. These groups periodically gather, on a voluntary basis, to discuss the profession. Typically at each meeting one of the members will present a topic, like a project experience, a research item, etc. It can also make sense to invite outside speakers. Each group has a chairperson and a secretary. The organization should stimulate with facilities, food, cost coverage of external speakers etc. This is a very cost-friendly way to build the testing and test automation profession, thus benefiting all projects involved.

 

LogiGear Corporation

LogiGear Corporation LogiGear Corporation provides global solutions for software testing, and offers public and corporate software-testing training programs worldwide through LogiGear University. LogiGear is a leader in the integration of test automation, offshore resources and US project management for fast and cost-effective results. Since 1994, LogiGear has worked with hundreds of companies from the Fortune 500 to early-stage startups, creating unique solutions to exactly meet their needs. With facilities in the US and Vietnam, LogiGear helps companies double their test coverage and improve software quality while reducing testing time and cutting costs. For more information, contact Joe Hughes + 01 650.572.1400

LogiGear Corporation
LogiGear Corporation provides global solutions for software testing, and offers public and corporate software testing training programs worldwide through LogiGear University. LogiGear is a leader in the integration of test automation, offshore resources and US project management for fast, cost-effective results. Since 1994, LogiGear has worked with Fortune 500 companies to early-stage start-ups in, creating unique solutions to meet their clients’ needs. With facilities in the US and Viet Nam, LogiGear helps companies double their test coverage and improve software quality while reducing testing time and cutting costs.

The Related Post

Mobile usage today is not just a trend but it is an essential shift in how people communicate with each other, interact with the world, and do business. According to a ComScore, in 2014 the number of mobile users surpassed the number of computer users and is showing strong growth over time, towards some point in ...
One of the basic challenges with test automation is adoption. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve cataloged licenses for a company and found out they already have many different automation software packages, none of which is being used. Traditionally I’ve been told that is because the tools don’t work and that the teams ...
June Issue 2019: Testing the Software Car
Over the years, we’ve provided an extensive number of articles that provide a wealth of knowledge about Test Automation. Below is a compilation of some of those articles. Guide to Automated Voice Apps Testing This article explores some of the basic test tools you’ll need and how to blend the use different automated testing tools ...
Introduction Many executives have some very basic questions about Software Testing. These questions address the elements of quality (customer satisfaction) and money (spending the least amount of money to prevent future loss). The basic questions that executive have about Software Testing include: Why care about and spend money on testing? Why should testing be treated ...
Test automation provides great benefits to the software testing process and improves the quality of the results. It improves reliability while minimizing variability in the results, speeds up the process, increases test coverage, and ultimately can provide greater confidence in the quality of the software being tested. However, automation is not a silver bullet. It ...
There are few topics in quality assurance testing that cause as much confusion as smoke testing versus sanity testing. The two names would seem to describe very different practices— and they do! But people still get them confused, since the distinction is somewhat subtle.
Looking for a solution to test your voice apps across devices and platforms? Whether you’re new or experienced in testing voice apps such as Alexa skill or Google Home actions, this article will give you a holistic view of the challenges of executing software testing for voice-based apps. It also explores some of the basic ...
In order to make the right choices among tools, you must be able to classify them. Otherwise, any choice would be at best haphazard. Without functioning classification, you would not be able to understand new tools fast, nor come up with ideas of using, or creating new tools.
The success of Automation is often correlated to its ROI. Here are 5 KPIs that we find universally applicable when it comes to quanitfying your Test Automation.
Understanding the benefits and challenges of Automating ERP is critical. According to SAP, ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) “is the core processes that are needed to run a company: finance, human resources, manufacturing, supply chain, services, procurement, and others. At its most basic level, ERP integrates these processes into a single system. But new ERP systems ...
Regardless of your current state of tools, building an effective Continuous Integration suite of significant automated regression tests is the key to moving to a higher level of confidence in today’s development world. In the evolution timeline of software development tools, new tools have recently proliferated. We have all been sold on collaboration, transparency and ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Stay in the loop with the lastest
software testing news

Subscribe